Isn't it possible to set Cmd-Shift-1 as keyboard shortcut for a menu item?

[japino]

I'm creating a standalone app for use on a Mac. I have a menu with 4 menu items.
Menu item 1 uses Cmd-1
Menu item 2 uses Cmd-2
Menu item 3 uses Cmd-Shift-1
Menu item 4 uses Cmd-Shift-2

At least.... that what's I would like them to be.

But the menu displays:
Menu item 1: Cmd-1
Menu item 2: Cmd-2
Menu item 3: Cmd-1
Menu item 4: Cmd-2

When I use Cmd-Shift-G and Cmd-Shift-B respectively for menu items 3 and 4, I do get expected shortscuts in the menu:
Menu item 1: Cmd-1
Menu item 2: Cmd-2
Menu item 3: Cmd-Shift-G
Menu item 4: Cmd-Shift-B

Why can't I set Cmd-Shift-1 or 2 as keyboard shortcut for a menu item?

[Klaus]

On a german keyboard:
SHIFT-1 = !
SHIFT-2 = "

So there is no CMD-SHIFT-1 actually, but CMD-!, maybe that is the reason?

[richmond62]

This 'thing' about CMD-SHIFT-1 has already been mentioned elsewhere by the same OP.
-

Commander.png (12.34 KiB) Viewed 2789 times

-
Mind you, inside LiveCode, at least, SHIFT-CMD-anything is a problem.

Code: Select all

on rawKeyUp RP
   put RP into fld "ff"
   if the commandKey is down then
      put "CMD " before fld "ff"
   end if
   if the shiftKey is down then
      put "SH " before fld "ff"
   end if
   if the altKey is down then
      put "ALT " before fld "ff"
   end if
end rawKeyUp

[japino]

Thanks Klaus and Richmond!

This 'thing' about CMD-SHIFT-1 has already been mentioned elsewhere by the same OP.

Uhh, did I really talk about this before? May be I did, my memory fails me (wouldn't be the first time).

Mind you, inside LiveCode, at least, SHIFT-CMD-anything is a problem

Yes, and I guess I sort of understand why now. (Actually I had "Option" instead of "Shift" at first. I wanted to use "Command-Option-1" and I didn't get that to display in the menu either.)

Because I couldn't figure this one out at first and I didn't want to use other keyboard shortcuts, I changed the way my app works, so that now I don't need those extra commands in the menu.